October 29, 2026
How many Saturday mornings did you spend circling the little lot on West San Marcos Boulevard, waiting for someone to finish their pancakes so you could park?
That lot was the reason Mama Kat's moved. Over the years Michael and Kristen Herrera kept taking over neighboring units in the building as they came open, and that gave them more seats. The parking lot never grew with them, as The Coast News reported when the restaurant reopened in August. The new home at 288 Rancheros Drive was the My Yard Live brewpub until it closed in November 2024. Before that it sat empty for several years after Hometown Buffet closed there in 2016, following an 18-year run.
This is the first Thanksgiving in the new building. Mama Kat's has always been a pie shop that happens to serve breakfast, and the bigger space hasn't changed that so far. The building is far bigger, but the hours and menu haven't changed yet, so the November pie rush will be the first busy season to put the extra space to work.
The San Diego Union-Tribune described the move as going from a 4,000-square-foot strip-mall space to an 18,500-square-foot indoor-outdoor building. By the paper's count, that more than doubles the seating. In a June interview with San Diego Beer News, the owners said the new site has triple the parking of the old one.
Triple the parking still wasn't enough on day one. At 9:45 a.m. on the Monday The Coast News stopped by, the lot was full, people were waiting for spaces, and the waiting areas were packed. One busy morning doesn't prove a pattern. Still, it's worth knowing before you plan a pickup run the week of Thanksgiving.
San Marcos also went most of the summer without Mama Kat's. San Diego Beer News reported that June 22, 2026 was the last service at the San Marcos Boulevard location. By August 24, the Monday The Coast News described, the new restaurant was open and full. That's about two months without the place, and it showed in the crowd once the doors opened.
The building doesn't feel like a brewpub anymore. The owners told San Diego Beer News they added a five-head barista station with its own cafe seating. They also added a waiting area meant to feel like someone's living room and a banquet room. The main dining room keeps the booths and an old-school diner counter, plus a large family-sized booth in the middle of the building.
Outside, they rebuilt the gazebo over the stage and swapped the artificial grass for decomposed granite. They also built a large pergola and a pond with a waterfall.
For longtime San Marcos residents, the best detail is on the wall. The Herreras worked with the San Marcos Historical Society on a display of framed photos from the city's early days. It includes founding farms, the oldest buildings, the first airports and the people who lived here then.
Ordering works differently too. The Union-Tribune reported that you can sit down for table service or order at the counter and grab free seating indoors or out. The old central bar is gone. If you just want coffee and a slice, the counter means you don't have to wait for a table.
The hours are still the old diner's hours. The official Mama Kat's hours page lists 7 a.m. to 1 p.m. every day. The Union-Tribune's September listing had a 7:30 a.m. weekday start and a 7 a.m. start Friday through Sunday, closing at 1 p.m. every day. Before you show up at 7 on a Tuesday, check the restaurant's own page.
The plans for the new building go well past 1 p.m. Here is where each one stood in the most recent reports:
| Plan | What the owners described | Where it stood in the latest reporting |
|---|---|---|
| Lunch menu | Bring back the lunch menu they served until 2020 | Signs in August said a new lunch menu was in development |
| Later hours | Stay open an hour or two later for the lunch crowd | Official hours still end at 1 p.m. |
| Early coffee | Quick-grab cafe service an hour before regular hours | Planned for after the restaurant settles in |
| Happy hour | Cocktails and appetizers for people after work | Being explored |
| Events | Live music, car shows, banquets and private events, one to five a month | Described as plans in June |
| House beer | A beer with "breakfast" in the name, plus guest taps from local breweries | Owners considering their own beer "someday," per the Union-Tribune |
The brewing equipment is still there. San Diego Beer News described the building as having a 10-barrel brewery, and the Union-Tribune confirmed the tanks stayed after the bar came out. The owners told San Diego Beer News they'd take their time with brewing and make sure they had the right team first. So for now it's a breakfast-and-pie room, with the equipment for much more already in the building.
Thanksgiving is when Mama Kat's kitchen carries its heaviest load. In 2018 Mama Kat's made about 2,000 pies in-house for Thanksgiving orders, according to The Coast News. Michael Herrera said they went through more than 1,000 pounds of pumpkin filling a season. Pumpkin was the top seller that year, followed by apple, apple cranberry and apple boysenberry. Each came with a traditional sugar crust or the Dutch topping made with rolled oats, brown sugar, butter, lemon and spices. Those figures are eight years old. They show how big the Thanksgiving rush is, but they don't tell you this year's menu.
All of that baking used to come out of a kitchen the owners called tight. They told San Diego Beer News the old location's cooking and storage space was so small that new menu ideas rarely got past the occasional special. The Rancheros Drive building came with a larger kitchen, along with all that dining and event space.
The pies go back further than the Mama Kat's name. Herrera bought Grandpa Allen's Family Restaurant in 2005 and renamed it for his mother in 2008. He told The Coast News in 2018 that the previous owner had been making pies there since the 1970s. Herrera learned by watching him bake from memory before high school, then weighing and measuring each batch to turn that skill into recipes. He described why the restaurant keeps baking them in that same interview:
"We still make pies because they make people remember a simpler time. They aren't the biggest profit generator but there is just something nostalgic about them that brings people back."
He also said Thanksgiving is the peak. The shop makes hundreds more pies before the December holidays, but November is when the kitchen works hardest.
This year Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26, four weeks from this Thursday. The Mama Kat's homepage currently carries a "We Are Back" message about the new restaurant. The 2026 order deadlines, pickup times and pie list haven't been posted there yet. Here's a simple way to plan the run:
When you go, take a minute at the Historical Society photo wall before you leave. Seeing the farms and first airfields the city grew from puts a new San Marcos building in context, and that's the kind of context I bring to buyers and sellers here every day. If you have questions about where San Marcos is headed, or just want a second opinion on your pie order, I'm happy to talk it over. Jeff Underdahl has been helping North County neighbors make smart moves for 36 years. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.